Unlock the Editor’s Digest free of charge
Roula Khalaf, Editor of the FT, selects her favorite tales on this weekly e-newsletter.
Constitution charges for ships carrying liquefied pure fuel have hit report lows, with some house owners now dealing with a loss in the event that they lease their vessels out, because the sector grapples with big overproduction within the wake of Europe’s vitality disaster two years in the past.
The price of hiring a contemporary LNG service — the dominant vessel kind in the marketplace — on a short-term foundation within the Atlantic basin was on common $19,700 a day in November, in keeping with information from Spark Commodities, the bottom assessed in information going again to 2019.
Charges have fallen practically 80 per cent for the reason that summer time, because the supply of latest ships outpaces the expansion in international LNG manufacturing.
Brokers, analysts and LNG merchants mentioned that headline charges for older, much less environment friendly vessels had plunged as effectively. For the LNG carriers that run on steam generators, probably the most inefficient in the marketplace, “the earnings, as soon as components reminiscent of operational prices are deducted, are in quite a lot of instances destructive or close to zero”, one dealer mentioned.
Such low charges imply some shipowners might not be capable of cowl their prices from letting their vessels out, and are prone to result in a interval of readjustment within the trade, as an example by the scrapping of older ships.
Destructive constitution charges for LNG carriers are uncommon however had been recorded by Spark in February 2022, within the run-up to Russia’s invasion of Ukraine. Gas prices, which Spark assumes the shipowners pay on the vessel’s ballast leg — when it’s not carrying cargo — soared as a result of imminent assault, resulting in destructive charges being assessed.
The autumn in constitution charges this yr has been pushed by the massive variety of vessels hitting the market at a time when the precise commodity they ship has not come on-line as shortly as anticipated on account of mission delays.
Shipowners had positioned a major variety of orders in the course of the European vitality disaster triggered by the Russian invasion. They had been betting that demand for seaborne gasoline would rise, pushed by Europe’s want to exchange misplaced Russian pipeline fuel with LNG imports, because the Kremlin started slashing provides even earlier than the full-scale struggle started.
There have been round 650 LNG carriers in operation as of final yr, in keeping with Worldwide Gasoline Union, an trade group. Sixty-eight vessels would have been added to that pool by the tip of this yr and 88 in 2025, in keeping with Flex LNG, an LNG delivery firm. Greater than 80 ships shall be delivered annually by way of to 2027, in keeping with Flex.
Nonetheless, the extra volumes of LNG exports that these vessels wee ordered for haven’t materialised within the timeframe anticipated, primarily on account of delays within the improvement of LNG export services within the US, now the world’s largest exporter of the superchilled gasoline and the primary supply for Europe.
LNG export volumes sometimes rise round 6 to eight per cent a yr, however this yr is prone to see just one per cent development, mentioned Oystein Kalleklev, CEO of Flex LNG, on an earnings name in November. “That is additionally one of many explanations why the [freight] spot market is buying and selling poorly,” he mentioned.
Moreover, Europe has not imported as a lot LNG as in earlier years as a result of excessive degree of fuel left in storage after final winter proved milder than regular, limiting the usage of such vessels.
Merchants additionally didn’t this yr utilise floating storage — preserving laden LNG vessels on the water till costs rise within the run-up to winter — as a lot as earlier years due to the shortage of a significant value distinction between summer time and winter costs. This has launched extra carriers.
Some older vessels are additionally being free of long-term contracts this yr, brokers say, including to the glut of ships.
Precise constitution offers at zero or destructive charges have up to now this time not taken place and stay theoretical for now, say brokers and analysts. Nonetheless, house owners of the older ships could also be inclined to lease them out at such charges — which might assist hold their LNG storage tanks on the crucial cool temperature — after weighing the prices of both taking them out of service or scrapping them.
“Actual constitution agreements might emerge the place house owners let loose a vessel at a headline charge of or near zero for a short while,” mentioned Clare Pennington, LNG delivery skilled at commodity consultancy ICIS. “What might occur is a state of affairs the place some house owners are caught with a steam vessel and are balancing the price of [taking it off market] or letting it out so it doesn’t heat up.
“It is going to additionally rely on how lengthy house owners might need to attend to scrap a vessel, and making calculations on what prices them much less,” she mentioned.
Whereas vitality firms forecast that demand for LNG will surge within the coming many years, principally from growing Asian nations switching their gasoline from coal to fuel, LNG freight charges within the quick time period are prone to be depressed, say analysts.
Martin Senior, deputy head of LNG pricing at Argus Media, a pricing company, mentioned that whereas 251 new-build carriers had been on account of be delivered between 2025 and 2027, the brand new export capability coming on-line in the identical interval would possibly require solely 171 further carriers.
“The market is pricing in a well-supplied LNG service market subsequent yr with ahead [freight] charges for 2025 far under ranges seen in earlier years,” Senior mentioned.
Further reporting by Oliver Telling
