My objective was to not mock all of the methods promoting out there prime. However to discover a stable method that may commerce reliably in the long term (6 months and longer).
General, I like to recommend specialists that:
– can commerce robotically for a minimum of 6 months (dwell alerts or specialists with out updates);
– can commerce a number of symbols;
– use an inexpensive risk-to-profit ratio (quantity 0.01 for each 1000 USD) and make positive aspects;
– don’t use Martingale;
– don’t depend on ChatGPT alerts (as a result of ChatGPT doesn’t present alerts).
Subsequently, I like to recommend:
10/ Large Foreign exchange Gamers MT5
14/ Commerce Assistant MT5
38/ Boring Pips MT5
I don’t advocate:
– Consultants that commerce Gold or Bitcoin, as a result of they principally guess on the expectation that Gold and Bitcoin will develop eternally. AI Gen XII EA (trades Gold) is failing proper now.
– Consultants that allegedly seek the advice of the ChatGPT bot on which course to commerce. Everyone knows ChatGPT doesn’t give precise info, it may solely present basic data or draw footage/motion pictures.
1/ CyNera MT5
146 purchases within the final month (up from 55)
62 critiques (approx. 600 whole purchases)
Max income of the writer approx. 500K USD
Not beneficial.
– Trades solely Gold. Alerts will not be lengthy sufficient.
– A really weak dense neural community which produces short-term trades on Gold. No drawdowns within the historic chart is a certain indication that it’s not a technique. It’s an all the time right curve-fitting.
2/ CyNeron MT5
107 purchases within the final month
12 critiques (approx. 120 whole purchases)
Max income of the writer approx. 100K USD
Not beneficial.
– Similar as above from the identical writer.
– Within the sign, trades for quantity 0.2-0.3 with a deposit of 1000 USD. One incorrect commerce will kill the account.
3/ Imply Machine
48 purchases within the final month
20 critiques (approx. 200 whole purchases)
Max income of the writer approx. 150K USD
Not beneficial.
– Sign just isn’t lengthy sufficient.
– Began a historic take a look at and acquired an empty chart for the 12 months 2024. It was apparently tweaked to cheat the market verification. Guys, that is rip-off that it may solely present its true functionality within the dwell mode. You may simulate any information, if not in MQL5, do it even simpler in Python.
4/ Quantum Emperor MT5
31 purchases within the final month (similar as earlier)
349 critiques (approx. 3500 whole purchases)
Max income of the writer approx. 2M USD
Not beneficial.
– Trades solely GBPUSD.
– It is a long-runner in the marketplace. In its historic chart, the blue steadiness line doesn’t “dance” with the inexperienced fairness line. It means it enters the market randomly and waits eternally for trades to change into worthwhile.
5/ Everlasting Engine EA MT5
64 purchases within the final month
15 critiques (approx. 150 whole purchases)
Max income of the writer approx. 55K USD
Not beneficial.
– In line with alerts, it’s a scalping system which holds trades for as much as a number of days and takes revenue of 10-20 pips.
– The sign of 78 weeks has made a revenue of 271 USD with the preliminary deposit of 1000 USD.
– In line with historic testing, the blue steadiness line doesn’t “dance” with the inexperienced fairness line. It means it enters the market randomly and waits eternally for trades to change into worthwhile.
6/ Executor AI UltraX MT5
68 purchases within the final month
17 critiques (approx. 170 whole purchases)
Max income of the writer approx. 75K USD
Not beneficial.
– Sign just isn’t lengthy sufficient.
– The sign is a 500 USD deposit, and it trades volumes of 0.2-0.4 on Gold. One incorrect commerce will kill the account.
7/ AI Golden Jet Fighter GTX MT5 (similar as earlier)
46 purchases within the final month
22 critiques (approx. 200 whole purchases)
Max income of the writer approx. 100K USD
Not beneficial.
– Sign just isn’t lengthy sufficient. A nasty ratio risk-to-profit within the sign. 30% drawdown.
– Curve-fitting within the historic chart.
8/ AI Gen XII EA
16 purchases within the final month (down from 127)
109 critiques (approx. 1000 whole purchases)
Max income of the writer approx. 500K USD
Not beneficial.
– Trades solely Gold.
– It was good with restrictions in my earlier assessments. I solely wanted extra sign historical past. Gold has been rising because the begin of this 12 months. Now Gold is caught, and hastily this professional is simply dropping. It was set as much as guess on Gold all the time going up-up-up. Which is nonsense. Like I stated, it’s not a technique.
9/ Quantum Queen MT5
29 purchases within the final month
52 critiques (approx. 520 whole purchases)
Max income of the writer approx. 250K USD
Not beneficial.
– In contrast to Quantum Emperor from the identical writer, this trades solely Gold.
– Loopy curve-fitting within the historic chart.
– Gold has been rising for the 12 months 2024. Now Gold is caught and is outwardly going to enter its ordinary harsh and unpredictable cycle. This professional goes to crash within the subsequent few months.
10/ Large Foreign exchange Gamers MT5
21 purchases within the final month
69 critiques (approx. 650 whole purchases)
Max income of the writer approx. 500K USD
Advisable.
– Trades totally different symbols.
– A scalper with a believable historic chart.
– No sign. Nevertheless, final replace was in Could 2024, and it wins within the historic take a look at since then.
11/ The Infinity EA MT5
40 purchases within the final month
8 critiques (approx. 80 whole purchases)
Max income of the writer approx. 40K USD
Not beneficial.
– Positively a rip-off. Description says it makes use of ChatGPT, with many properties suggesting it consults the ChatGPT bot. Everybody is aware of ChatGPT doesn’t give info on which course to commerce.
– No sign but.
– No buying and selling in historic testing since April.
12/ Quantum Bitcoin EA
25 purchases within the final month
14 critiques (approx. 140 whole purchases)
Max income of the writer approx. 75K USD
Not beneficial.
– One other rip-off from the identical writer. Bitcoin began rising once more on the expectation that D. Trump will favor e-currencies. This professional bets totally on shopping for as a result of Bitcoin is rising. “Quantum Emperor MT5” doesn’t work like this as a result of GBPUSD just isn’t rising. “Quantum Queen” is already failing as a result of Gold has stopped rising.
– Bitcoin has a really restricted quantity of historic patterns. It is vitally laborious to coach a neural community on the historical past of Bitcoin. So when it’ll fail, it’ll fail very-very laborious.
13/ Gold One
89 purchases within the final month
14 critiques (approx. 140 whole purchases)
Max income of the writer approx. 20K USD
Not beneficial.
– Historic testing appears to be like believable. Nevertheless, it checks very slowly even on “1 minute OHLC”. My understanding is that the writer is simply beginning with MQL5 and buying and selling.
– A sign for “Past One” from the identical writer opens trades with quantity 0.1-0.2 and a deposit of 100 USD. It’s actually a infantile buying and selling. This account might be immediately killed by one incorrect commerce. Which confirms that the writer is a newbie.
– No sign for “Gold One”.
14/ Commerce Assistant MT5
325 purchases within the final month
225 critiques (approx. 2250 whole purchases)
Max income of the writer approx. 200K USD
Advisable.
– A pleasant-looking device for guide buying and selling.
– Doesn’t assist making an actual revenue however it may switch a sense that you’re doing one thing good on Foreign exchange.
15/ Vortex Gold EA
29 purchases within the final month
8 critiques (approx. 80 whole purchases)
Max income of the writer approx. 40K USD
Not beneficial.
– It’s a grid. Very small earnings for lots of pending orders on the identical day. If it goes the incorrect approach (which Gold can do in a short time), it is going to be a tough crash.
16/ Synapse Dealer MT5
11 purchases within the final month
1 critiques (approx. 15 whole purchases)
Max income of the writer approx. 7.5K USD
Not beneficial.
– A sign trades with volumes of 0.5-0.6 and a deposit of 500 USD. It is going to crash brutally.
– A pleasant historic chart tells it’s a rip-off.
17/ GbpUsd Robotic MT5
81 purchases within the final month
27 critiques (approx. 270 whole purchases)
Max income of the writer approx. 80K USD
Not beneficial.
– A pleasant historic chart tells it’s a rip-off.
– No buying and selling because the final replace and no clarification.
– No sign for a really lengthy record of merchandise.
18/ London Bell
6 purchases within the final month
No critiques
Max income of the writer approx. 6K USD
Not beneficial.
– Just about no buying and selling in historic testing. A really gradual take a look at even for the final month, even on “1 minute OHLC”. The writer is an absolute newbie in MQL5 and buying and selling.
– Within the sign, very small earnings for lots of trades on the identical day. Scalping specialists all the time lose each time the market begins transferring very quick and really massive.
19/ Secret Impulse
22 purchases within the final month
4 critiques (approx. 40 whole purchases)
Max income of the writer approx. 16K USD
Not beneficial.
– Trades solely Gold.
– A really awful image of historic buying and selling for the 12 months 2024.
– Buying and selling on the sign just isn’t 100% automated. Very small earnings for lots of trades on the identical day.
20/ Midas Killer
9 purchases within the final month
No critiques
Max income of the writer approx. 4.5K USD
Not beneficial.
– It locations pending orders of 80 pips TP and SL on Gold. Gold simply strikes 500 pips in a single day. It will likely be an enormous loser in a flat market with massive returning strikes.
– In a historic take a look at, it is determined by once you begin. And no clarification. Which makes me suppose it’s the easiest grid system.
21/ Wall Avenue Killer
29 purchases within the final month
16 critiques (approx. 160 whole purchases)
Max income of the writer approx. 48K USD
Not beneficial.
– Historic chart in some way avoids all lengthy strikes, creating nearly zero drawdowns. It’s merely not potential in actual market situations, it’s curve-fitting.
– Trades solely the American index “US30”.
– A scalper with a mean holding time of 1 minute?!
– Sign just isn’t lengthy sufficient.
22/ Bitcoin Robotic MT5
19 purchases within the final month
62 critiques (approx. 620 whole purchases)
Max income of the writer approx. 500K USD
Not beneficial.
– Historic take a look at with a 90% drawdown in 4 years. The longer term might have any costs. The previous can be any costs. For those who see 90% drawdown previously, you will notice it sooner or later.
– As I already stated, Bitcoin is tough to commerce robotically. It has a really restricted historical past to seek for buying and selling patterns.
– No sign for an extended record of merchandise from this writer.
23/ Reverse Grid MT5
58 purchases within the final month
17 critiques (approx. 170 whole purchases)
Max income of the writer approx. 12K USD
Not beneficial.
– This man is an absolute newbie. He factors on the absolute drawdown in his historic chart, which is 1.2%. The actual drawdown is relative, and it’s 15%.
– If you may make 20M USD on the hourly chart of EURUSD in 2024 alone, why promoting this miracle?
– No sign. Merely keep away from it.
24/ Tokyo Sizzling MT5
6 purchases within the final month
No critiques
Max income of the writer approx. 6K USD
Not beneficial.
– Within the sign, very small earnings for lots of trades on the identical day. Scalping specialists all the time lose each time the market begins transferring very quick and really massive.
25/ Gold Scalping AI MT5
27 purchases within the final month
3 critiques (approx. 30 whole purchases)
Max income of the writer approx. 8K USD
Not beneficial.
– No buying and selling since 2020 in historic testing. I’d keep away from merchandise from an writer who can not even arrange a historic demonstration.
– A sign for Gold must be a minimum of 6 months lengthy to make a stable judgement. Gold can transfer so quick, it may destroy your account with this professional in a single transfer.
26/ ProTwentyT
13 purchases within the final month
5 critiques (approx. 50 whole purchases)
Max income of the writer approx. 1K USD
Not beneficial.
– A easy martingale professional. It locations reverse pending orders, each of which set off. It then waits for them to both make a revenue or be closed by stoploss.
– It’s not utilizing an growing quantity, but it surely doesn’t make it Martingale.
– Alerts are for a deposit of 100 USD. The writer is a newbie in Foreign currency trading.
27/ Gold Scalping Professional mt5
227 purchases within the final month
64 critiques (approx. 640 whole purchases)
Max income of the writer approx. 19K USD
Not beneficial.
– A 15-minute scalper on Gold?!
– The professional has not been up to date since October twenty second. It checks properly since then, which is about 2 months. We want a minimum of 6 months of computerized buying and selling (a dwell sign or an professional with out updates).
– My level is that Gold is the image that makes massive and long-lasting strikes. It’s best to guess on these, as a result of in any other case you’ll lose every part in a single 12 months of buying and selling.
28/ The Gold Phoenix
5 purchases within the final month
3 critiques (approx. 30 whole purchases)
Max income of the writer approx. 25K USD
Not beneficial.
– Just like the “Imply Machine” from this writer, I began a historic take a look at and acquired an empty chart for the 12 months 2024.
– Sign not lengthy sufficient.
– It says it makes use of ChatGPT to assist make higher buying and selling choices. It is a rip-off, as a result of everyone knows ChatGPT doesn’t present precise info on which course to commerce.
29/ The Matrix Thoughts AI MT5
12 purchases within the final month
No critiques
Max income of the writer approx. 5K USD
Not beneficial.
– Sign not lengthy sufficient.
– The sign trades volumes of as much as 1.0 for a deposit of 700 USD. It is going to destroy the account with one incorrect commerce.
30/ CoreX G
Lower than 10 purchases within the final month (down from 30)
10 critiques (approx. 100 whole purchases)
Max income of the writer approx. 50K USD
Not beneficial.
– A straight-line historic chart tells us it’s a rip-off.
– 23 weeks of sign, and we see that the professional trades quantity of as much as 0.21 for a deposit of 300 USD. One incorrect commerce can destroy the account.
30/ Apocalypse Gold
15 purchases within the final month
16 critiques (approx. 160 whole purchases)
Max income of the writer approx. 32K USD
Not beneficial.
– A 5-minute scalper on Gold?! One massive transfer or a sequence of incorrect trades can kill the account in a matter of 2-3 hours.
– Says it trades on totally different symbols, however principally Gold trades within the sign.
– A 20 USD deposit within the sign!? This the bottom quantity I’ve seen. We all know that human phsychology doesn’t deal with the identical approach small and massive deposits.
31/ King Sniper EA
17 purchases within the final month
2 critiques (approx. 20 whole purchases)
Max income of the writer approx. 5K USD
Not beneficial.
– A 20 USD deposit within the sign. We all know that human phsychology doesn’t deal with the identical approach small and massive deposits.
– A Martingale grid. Many pending orders, usually reverse pending orders.
– The inexperienced fairness line abruptly goes beneath the blue steadiness line within the historic chart. It opens trades and not using a technique, merely within the hope that it might come its approach ultimately. That is pure Martingale playing. Keep away, it’s all the time dropping the long term.
32/ Aurum AI mt5
24 purchases within the final month
16 critiques (approx. 160 whole purchases)
Max income of the writer approx. 45K USD
Not beneficial.
– A 5-minute scalper on Gold?!
– 2M from 2K in a single 12 months within the historic take a look at. Give me a break.
– Sign not lengthy sufficient.
– Volumes of 0.05-0.1 for a 400 USD deposit within the sign. One massive transfer within the incorrect course can kill the account.
33/ Bitcoin Scalping MT5
30 purchases within the final month
3 critiques (approx. 30 whole purchases)
Max income of the writer approx. 9K USD
Not beneficial.
– It’s a grid. This method is all the time dropping in the long term.
– Bitcoin doesn’t have sufficient historical past to have the ability to practice a neural community. It wants patterns. For Bitcoin, there is just one dependable sample – purchase it and maintain it. Keep away from specialists that commerce solely Bitcoin or solely Gold.
– Sign not lengthy sufficient.
34/ Quantum StarMan
Lower than 10 purchases within the final month
103 critiques (approx. 1030 whole purchases)
Max income of the writer approx. 350K USD
Not beneficial.
– It’s a grid.
– The inexperienced fairness line abruptly goes beneath the blue steadiness line within the historic chart. It opens trades and not using a technique, merely within the hope that it might come its approach ultimately.
– A multi-symbol method will not assist on this state of affairs.
– Sign not lengthy sufficient.
35/ HFT PropFirm EA MT5
14 purchases within the final month
30 critiques (approx. 300 whole purchases)
Max income of the writer approx. 60K USD
Not beneficial.
– It locations just about a whole lot of pending order in a single day within the historic take a look at. I assume the writer is an absolute newbie in MQL5 and on Foreign exchange.
– No sign for this professional.
– One other sign buying and selling Gold from this writer has made a revenue of 43 USD on a 1000 USD deposit in 30 weeks.
36/ Aura Black Version MT5
5 purchases within the final month
34 critiques (approx. 340 whole purchases)
Max income of the writer approx. 150K USD
Not beneficial.
– I bear in mind one other one “Aura White Version MT5” from this writer. It was within the prime 10 of the market as of June 1st 2024. And I bear in mind my remark: “A sign of 4 weeks which is nowhere just like its good historic chart.”
– Sign not lengthy sufficient.
– 3M from 2K in a single 12 months. Give me a break.
37/ Aura Neuron MT5
9 purchases within the final month
6 critiques (approx. 60 whole purchases)
Max income of the writer approx. 40K USD
Not beneficial.
– Many copies of a single method from the identical writer, all buying and selling Gold and dropping after 1-2 months.
– Sign not lengthy sufficient.
38/ Boring Pips MT5
Lower than 10 purchases within the final month
34 critiques (approx. 340 whole purchases)
Max income of the writer approx. 250K USD
Advisable.
– A sign over a 12 months with a stable revenue.
– A believable historic chart.
– Why not well-liked? I assume the writer didn’t deal with correctly the enter properties, and non-USD deposits do not make a revenue for no matter motive.
39/ Aura Neuron MT5
Lower than 10 purchases within the final month (down from 41)
20 critiques (approx. 200 whole purchases)
Max income of the writer approx. 120K USD
Not beneficial.
– Trades solely GBPUSD.
– A straight-line historic chart, nowhere close to to its 6-week sign.
40/ Scalper Deriv
Lower than 10 purchases within the final month
15 critiques (approx. 150 whole purchases)
Max income of the writer approx. 50K USD
Not beneficial.
– Says it may commerce on any image. But it surely crashes in a really comparable approach on any image in historic testing.
– No sign.
41/ US100 Nasdaq EA
Lower than 10 purchases within the final month
9 critiques (approx. 90 whole purchases)
Max income of the writer approx. 40K USD
Not beneficial.
– Sign not lengthy sufficient.
– Historic testing doesn’t begin or runs with an empty chart.
42/ Prime Pattern Plus
Lower than 10 purchases within the final month
3 critiques (approx. 30 whole purchases)
Max income of the writer approx. 15K USD
Not beneficial.
– One other 5-minute scalper from the identical writer, which may commerce totally different symbols. One massive transfer or a sequence of incorrect trades can kill the account in a matter of 2-3 hours.
– Sign for a 50 USD deposit. 2 trades every week with a mean holding time of 8 hours. That could be a 5-minute mult-symbol scalper?!
– Doesn’t commerce in historic testing.
43/ Provide Demand EA ProBot MT5
Lower than 10 purchases within the final month
12 critiques (approx. 120 whole purchases)
Max income of the writer approx. 55K USD
Not beneficial.
– From the outline: “totally automated”, “over 15 thousand strains of code”. Nevertheless, it’s meant for guide buying and selling solely.
– No sign.
44/ Goldenity AI
Lower than 10 purchases within the final month
1 overview (approx. 10 whole purchases)
Max income of the writer approx. 5K USD
Not beneficial.
– The sign trades 1 week with a 1000 USD deposit and volumes as much as 0.1. One incorrect commerce can kill the account.
– The historic chart appears to be like believable, however I can not imagine in scalpers, particularly scalpers for Gold. Wants extra dwell buying and selling.
45/ Prometheus AI Gold
Lower than 10 purchases within the final month
1 overview (approx. 10 whole purchases)
Max income of the writer approx. 2.5K USD
Not beneficial.
– Began a historic take a look at, and acquired a 90% drawdown with 7 trades in 2024.
– A large number of professional properties. The writer ought to manage the properties as a tree of selections and present solely the necessary choices.
– Clearly, no sign.
46/ EA Gold Stuff mt5
Lower than 10 purchases within the final month
754 overview (approx. 7540 whole purchases)
Max income of the writer approx. 220K USD
Not beneficial.
– 1-minute scalper for Gold!? Wow, that’s the one. Did a historic take a look at, goes straight downwards.
– Trades with volumes as much as 1.0 for a 1000 USD deposit within the sign. One incorrect commerce can kill the account.
– Sign not lengthy sufficient.
47/ CyBRG RX
Lower than 10 purchases within the final month
13 overview (approx. 130 whole purchases)
Max income of the writer approx. 65K USD
Not beneficial.
– A 6-month sign with a 33% drawdown. And we all know, that we must always keep away from.
– A pleasant historic chart with no drawdowns tells us it’s a rip-off.
48/ Golden Ai EA MT5
Lower than 10 purchases within the final month
49 overview (approx. 490 whole purchases)
Max income of the writer approx. 170K USD
Not beneficial.
– No alerts for an extended record of merchandise from this writer.
– A pleasant historic chart as much as November 2nd, when was the final replace. And since that date, it’s a whole crash in historic testing. The writer is an absolute newbie in Foreign currency trading and machine studying.
49/ The Gold Reaper MT5
Lower than 10 purchases within the final month (down from 46)
79 overview (approx. 790 whole purchases)
Max income of the writer approx. 180K USD
Not beneficial.
– Was within the 2nd place of the market prime as of August 1st 2024.
– A 46-week sign is a complete crash.
– An extremely disappointing historic take a look at for the 2024.
50/ Eagle Odyssey
Lower than 10 purchases within the final month
2 overview (approx. 20 whole purchases)
Max income of the writer approx. 10K USD
Not beneficial.
– A pleasant historic take a look at tells us it’s a rip-off. 17M from 2K in a single 12 months. Give me a break.
– Sign not lengthy sufficient.
