Keep knowledgeable with free updates
Merely signal as much as the Agriculture myFT Digest — delivered on to your inbox.
US egg costs are quickly declining after a chook flu epidemic pushed them to report highs final month, prompting questions on whether or not producers had saved them artificially excessive.
Wholesale egg costs have fallen 54 per cent prior to now 4 weeks to $3.91 per dozen on Friday, in line with commodity worth info service Expana.
The American Egg Board, a commerce group that represents egg farmers, credited an absence of serious avian flu outbreaks prior to now month and farmers’ efforts to rebuild their flocks for the plummeting costs.
But economists mentioned that the precipitous drop accelerated days after US media reported that the justice division had opened an investigation into worth gouging by egg producers. The high price of eggs had come to symbolise the persevering with ache felt by US shoppers from persistent inflation.
Advocacy teams for small farmers and shoppers have lengthy accused the nation’s dominant egg producers — Cal-Maine Foods and Rose Acre Farms — of deliberately preserving costs excessive to extend income.
“This means to me that the costs didn’t must be as excessive as they have been,” mentioned David Anderson, a professor of economics and enterprise at Centre Faculty in Kentucky, “in the event that they may very well be dropped seemingly so shortly and simply.”
Emily Metz, chief government of the American Egg Board, dismissed the allegations as “conspiracy theories.” Cal-Maine Meals didn’t reply to a request for remark and Rose Acre Farms declined to remark.
“The egg trade is within the struggle of our lives,” Metz mentioned.
The avian flu epidemic started in 2022 however intensified in current months, forcing farmers to cull some 30mn birds to this point this 12 months and creating an egg scarcity that Metz expects to final no less than till the tip of the 12 months. The value rises that adopted elevated scrutiny of the trade, which is closely consolidated between a handful of firms.
“They get all they will till somebody sees their hand within the cookie jar, after which they are going to again off actual fast,” mentioned Joe Maxwell, co-founder of advocacy group Farm Motion.
Maxwell and different advocates say that the biggest US egg producers are being considerably slower to rebuild their flocks than they have been over the last chook flu outbreak in 2015, arguing that they might have deliberately restricted egg provides to maintain costs elevated.
Cal-Maine Meals final month reported $356mn in gross quarterly income, a fourfold improve from a 12 months prior.
Jeremy Horpedahl, an economics professor on the College of Central Arkansas, mentioned he was “sceptical” that farmers would have the ability to efficiently repair costs with out illegally co-ordinating with each other, of which there is no such thing as a proof.
Agriculture secretary Brooke Rollins credited the Trump administration’s $1bn plan to decrease costs by importing eggs and increasing reduction for affected farmers amongst different measures.
But Amy Smith, vice-president at meals and agriculture consultancy Superior Financial Options, mentioned it was “nonetheless too quickly” to see any impression from Trump’s efforts. The imported eggs have been sufficient to “cowl brunch for sooner or later on this nation”, she added.
Whereas retailers and restaurant house owners welcomed the worth drop after promoting eggs at a loss for months, shoppers are nonetheless paying close to record prices on the grocery retailer. A dozen grade-A big eggs value $5.90 final month in US cities on common, a 97 per cent improve from a 12 months earlier and essentially the most in additional than a decade, in line with the Bureau of Labor Statistics.
Horpedahl mentioned that whereas grocery retailer costs had fallen by as a lot as a greenback per dozen in some locations — costs are actually nearer to $4 per dozen in Texas — it may very well be weeks earlier than most US customers see reduction. Present inventories have been in all probability bought at increased wholesale costs and retailers would wish to recoup their funding, he mentioned.
“Everyone seems to be asking if this worth lower is for actual and if it’ll final,” Anderson at Centre Faculty mentioned. “Nobody is bound what’s going to occur.”
