Unlock the Editor’s Digest without spending a dime
Roula Khalaf, Editor of the FT, selects her favorite tales on this weekly publication.
“Contango” evokes photographs of dusky dancers from La Boca in Buenos Aires. If solely issues had been that romantic. As a substitute, it refers back to the scenario that happens whereas utilizing monetary futures contracts through which property are cheaper at this time than a later time limit.
In commodity markets, a futures curve in contango will encourage merchants to purchase, say, crude oil at at this time’s value, place that in storage and lock in a better value by promoting futures contracts sooner or later sooner or later. That assumes there may be adequate space for storing and financing to do all this.
The Trump administration’s cack-handed commerce tariff coverage bulletins, notably these involving China, have made everybody a bit jumpy about oil demand. The Opec+ resolution in early April to elevate oil manufacturing by 411,000 barrels per day from Might, practically triple the anticipated quantity, solely added concern of oversupplied oil markets.
All this has meant near-term oil costs preserve falling, which sounds bearish. However the actuality is that the oil curve’s form suggests a extra constructive outlook for oil than one would possibly assume.
Merchants care little concerning the path of the spot (or flat) value of commodities reminiscent of oil. What grabs their consideration is the behaviour of the futures curve and whether or not the value slopes upward (contango) or downward (backwardation). Often, a curve in contango encourages inventories to construct up and seems throughout bearish intervals. Backwardation implies the alternative: constructive near-term demand for crude, and with that low shares of oil.
For many of the final seven years, the oil curve has been in backwardation. Previous cuts to manufacturing by Opec+ have helped to keep up this example. As a proxy for the curve, take a look at the historic unfold between the near-term futures value and that for one 12 months away. A adverse distinction (backwardation) has continued for years, other than throughout the pandemic 12 months of 2020.
That implies concern a couple of lack of provide of the smelly black stuff. But the US-China commerce stand off has adverse demand implications for each economies, the world’s two largest oil shoppers. Extra provide is coming from the Opec+ producers. Shouldn’t the curve be in contango as oil inventories construct up?
Actually there are many bears on the market. Right here’s what Citi’s oil workforce wrote earlier this month:
Bodily oil markets will seemingly bear the brunt of the commerce tariff associated actual exercise shock within the coming weeks and months, with flat costs and construction [the oil curve] prone to transfer decrease. We lately introduced ahead our bearish [second half 2025] Brent value $60/bbl forecast to the 0-3-month view, in a well timed response to reciprocal tariffs.
And even by bizarre requirements, issues are bizarre. As Morgan Stanley analysts wrote in a be aware on Tuesday:
The Brent ahead curve has an uncommon form in the mean time: downward sloping throughout the primary 9 contracts and upward sloping thereafter… That is so uncommon that, actually, there may be little historic precedent for this.
There are historic examples the place the curve is downward sloping proper on the very entrance, say between the first and 2nd contract, after which turns upward-sloping thereafter. Nonetheless, in ~30 years of historic information, there has not been one other interval when the ahead curve confirmed a ‘smile’ the best way it presently does, with the low level across the ninth month contract.
Oil shocks previously have had an instantaneous impact on demand and provide. Bear in mind the adverse costs of oil in early 2020, when provide appeared to overwhelm storage capability? Issues are completely different at this time.
Firstly, international stock is fairly low. For example, the 25mn barrels in storage at Cushing, Oklahoma — an essential hub for the US oil benchmark traded at Nymex — represents a 19-year low for this time of 12 months. Secondly, the profitability of oil refiners is wholesome sufficient to maintain their demand for crude oil inputs regular.
Valerie Panopio at Rystad Vitality factors out that refiners are doing fairly nicely as their profitability is above the ten 12 months common. A diffusion of the Brent crude value in opposition to the costs of refined merchandise — petrol and diesel — made out of a barrel of oil offers a sign of the profitability.
“Individuals fear about future oil demand,” says Kitt Haines, in control of oil analysis at Vitality Elements:
However the low stage of [oil inventory] and [stable] refining margins make this a wierd scenario. In contrast to the worldwide monetary disaster or Covid intervals, we will see this unhealthy interval [for oil] coming however we will’t time it.
Joel Hanley at S&P World Commodity Insights agrees:
There’s positively a way that weaker demand progress expectations and potential for extra provide will weigh closely on the oil market, and doubtlessly result in a contango.”
The issue is that everybody has waited for Opec + to extend manufacturing for a 12 months or extra. Worse, completely different merchants and buyers, with typically opposing views, are making a bizarre scenario.
“You might have completely different gamers on completely different elements of the curve. There are quite a lot of [commodity trading advisers] pushing down the flat value. They’re buying and selling probably the most liquid two entrance months,” says Ryan Fitzmaurice, an oil dealer at Marex. “Then others are internet lengthy given the oil curve’s backwardation. Then, later within the curve, some merchants are taking part in the contango.”
To confuse issues extra, between December 2025 and 2026 the curve slopes upward in contango.
Opec+ won’t need the total oil curve to shift into contango as it might encourage large stock builds. “With the backwardation, Opec+ controls oil inventories,” factors out Panopio at Rystad. “But when contango comes via then the merchants will management oil shares.”
Dangerous information for Opec.
