Keep knowledgeable with free updates
Merely signal as much as the Oil & Gasoline trade myFT Digest — delivered on to your inbox.
A bitter dispute between ExxonMobil and Chevron over possession of a huge oil mission with as much as $1tn in reserves is scheduled to be heard earlier than an arbitration court docket in London on Monday, in a case with large implications for each firms and the broader trade.
The US supermajors are battling over the correct to amass a 30 per cent stake in Guyana’s Stabroek oilfield which is owned by Hess, a US vitality firm that agreed to a $53bn takeover by Chevron in September 2023.
Exxon, which owns 45 per cent of Stabroek, claims it has “proper of first refusal” to purchase Hess’s stake within the oilfield beneath the phrases of a joint working settlement (JOA) with Hess and one other accomplice, Cnooc, the Chinese language oil and gasoline firm. Cnooc, with 25 per cent of the oilfield, has filed a declare looking for the identical pre-emption proper.
Legal professionals are monitoring the Worldwide Chamber of Commerce arbitration to find out whether or not future JOAs will should be up to date to replicate the result of Exxon’s case, which includes pre-emptive rights — contractual provisions giving a celebration the correct to purchase an asset earlier than it’s supplied to others.
Stabroek is likely one of the most profitable oil discoveries in latest many years with an estimated 11bn barrels of oil reserves and additional exploration prone to enhance this determine. The mission has reworked Exxon’s fortunes, enabling it to reclaim its place as essentially the most worthwhile US oil firm after briefly being eclipsed by Chevron in October 2020.
Over the subsequent 15 years Exxon and its companions are forecast to generate $182bn in income from oil and gasoline gross sales from the Guyana oilfields, in accordance with Wooden Mackenzie, an vitality consultancy. Guyana’s authorities ought to obtain greater than $190bn, an unlimited sum for a rustic that was one of many poorest in South America till Exxon struck oil in 2015.
“Guyana is likely one of the most prized oil and gasoline tasks on the planet. It was developed in report time, offers comparatively low-emissions oil at a break-even value that’s under $30 a barrel, which makes it tremendous worthwhile,” mentioned Luiz Hayum, an analyst at Wooden Mackenzie.
Chevron, which isn’t a direct participant within the arbitration case, is determined to push forward with its Hess acquisition to entry the corporate’s Guyana belongings. Final yr Chevron’s oil and gasoline reserves fell to 9.8bn barrels, down from 11.1bn barrels in 2023, the bottom in additional than a decade.
Mike Wirth, Chevron chief govt, has mentioned he’s assured the corporate will prevail over Exxon. “This has been studied extensively, and we really feel like they clearly have the correct facet of this argument,” he instructed a Goldman Sachs convention in January.
In March, Chevron disclosed it had purchased virtually 5 per cent of Hess shares on the open market, an uncommon transfer which analysts interpreted as an indication the corporate is assured the long-delayed transaction will proceed.
However Exxon chief govt Darren Woods has additionally talked up the corporate’s prospects and claimed final yr it’s “standing up for what we imagine is a elementary proper”.
The listening to will probably be held in personal earlier than a three-judge panel. Sources near the method instructed the Monetary Instances the case most likely hinges on the interpretation of some phrases associated to pre-emptive rights within the JOA, which has not been revealed by any of the events.
Legal professionals for Hess are anticipated to argue {that a} proper of first refusal clause contained within the JOA solely applies when one of many companions seeks to promote the Guyana belongings, and never in a company takeover. Exxon is anticipated to argue the clause covers Chevron’s takeover of Hess as a result of the Guyana belongings makes up about 70 per cent of the worth of the complete firm.
“Exxon will argue Hess is principally an enormous Guyana asset and a bunch of rats and mice. In different phrases, all the pieces else is fairly insignificant,” mentioned one veteran oil govt with expertise of JOAs.
David Hoffman, a professor of legislation at College of Pennsylvania, mentioned the result might form how future JOAs are drafted.
“As a result of a lot cash is at stake right here I’m certain the related attorneys will perceive what the dispute is about and they’ll know who wins and they’ll attempt to alter their apply accordingly,” he mentioned.
Analysts mentioned the result was extra necessary for Chevron than Exxon due to the corporate’s want to seek out progress alternatives and increase its oil reserves.
“If Mike Wirth completes Hess he’s in good condition to retire and go away his period in cost as a hero. But when Chevron loses then he might have a unique large deal, like Oxy [Occidental Petroleum], to cement his lengthy legacy,” mentioned Paul Sankey, an oil analyst.
