Analyzing 3 Live EA Signals: The Real Performance Data Behind GBP, Gold, and AI Trading – My Trading – 25 November 2025

What 3 Actual Myfxbook Indicators Truly Present

Everybody talks about EA efficiency in backtests. Charts going up and to the proper. Excellent fairness curves. 99% win charges.

Then you definitely run it dwell and watch actuality hit totally different.

This is what I am doing as an alternative: analyzing 3 dwell, verified Myfxbook alerts which have been working for months. Actual cash. Actual dealer. Actual outcomes—good and dangerous.

No cherry-picked screenshots. No “simply belief me” guarantees. Simply Myfxbook hyperlinks you may confirm your self and the actual numbers behind them.

Let me break down what every sign reveals, what shocked me, and what this implies in the event you’re excited about working a number of EAs.

Sign #1: DoIt GBP Grasp (The Constant Grinder)

Myfxbook: DoIt GBP Grasp

The Numbers (Actual-Time Verified):

• Acquire: +140.29% (since inception)
• Month-to-month Acquire: 8.47% common
• Most Drawdown: 16.79%
• Win Charge: 92% (879 wins, 72 losses)
• Revenue Issue: 2.24
• Complete Trades: 951
• Common Commerce Period: 14 hours 27 minutes
• Pair: GBPUSD
• Platform: MT5, RoboForex

Word on dealer choice: All three alerts run on RoboForex due to steady spreads throughout energetic periods. Incorrect dealer = totally different outcomes. Verify EA dealer compatibility testing earlier than working any EA dwell.

What This Truly Means:

It is a grinder. Not horny. Not explosive. Simply constant compounding at 8.47% month-to-month.

951 trades is sufficient information to know this is not luck. If you see 92% win price over almost 1,000 trades, that is statistical significance.

However this is what the numbers do not scream at you: 16.79% most drawdown.

Meaning in the event you began with $10,000, you watched it drop to $8,321 on the worst level. Are you able to psychologically deal with that? Most cannot. They pull the plug proper earlier than restoration.

The Commerce Profile:

• Common win: 9.56 pips / €1.50
• Common loss: -70.54 pips / -€8.20
• Greatest commerce: €44.02 (62.4 pips)
• Worst commerce: -€43.19 (-251.4 pips)

That is basic high-win-rate, small-win-big-loss profile. Wins 92% of the time for small good points. When it loses (8% of trades), it loses larger. However the math works: 2.24 revenue issue proves it.

Common commerce period of 14 hours means this is not scalping. It is catching traits on M15 timeframe, using them by way of London + NY periods, exiting with tight trailing stops.

What Stunned Me:

The consistency. 951 trades with out blowing up. Month-to-month achieve of 8.47% each single month (on common). That is what skilled EA buying and selling seems to be like—boring, regular, compound progress.

Myfxbook: DoIt Gold Guardian

The Numbers (Actual-Time Verified):

• Acquire: +108.76%
• Month-to-month Acquire: 8.83% common
• Most Drawdown: 32.71%
• Win Charge: 95% (longs: 97%, shorts: 0%)
• Revenue Issue: 4.44
• Complete Trades: 109
• Common Commerce Period: 1 day
• Pair: XAUUSD (Gold)
• Platform: MT5, RoboForex

What This Truly Means:

That is the high-risk, high-reward profile.

Very first thing that jumps out: 32.71% most drawdown. Practically double the GBP Grasp. In the event you began with $10,000, you watched it drop to $6,729 in some unspecified time in the future.

Are you able to abdomen that? Be sincere.

However take a look at the revenue issue: 4.44. That is distinctive. For each greenback risked, this method makes $4.44. The win price of 95% means it is profitable nearly each commerce.

The Commerce Profile:

• Common win: 1,166.40 pips / $11.22
• Common loss: -5,049.06 pips / -$52.60
• Greatest commerce: $58.33 (5,833 pips!)
• Worst commerce: -$168.71 (-16,813 pips!)

That is excessive. Wins are +1,166 pips. Losses are -5,049 pips. But it nonetheless works as a result of it wins 95% of the time.

Solely 109 trades. This is not buying and selling daily. Common commerce period of 1 day means it is selective, ready for high-probability gold setups.

What Stunned Me:

The truth that 32.71% drawdown did not blow the account. Most merchants would’ve panicked and stopped the EA throughout that drawdown. However in the event you survived it, you are up +108.76%.

Because of this self-discipline issues greater than the EA. The EA did its job. The query is: would you will have let it?

Myfxbook: DoIt Alpha Pulse AI Default

The Numbers (Actual-Time Verified):

• Acquire: +41.51%
• Month-to-month Acquire: 31.70% (brief timeframe, early information)
• Most Drawdown: 30.74%
• Win Charge: 39% (274 wins, 427 losses)
• Revenue Issue: 1.15
• Complete Trades: 701
• Common Commerce Period: 55 minutes
• Pair: XAUUSD (Gold)
• Platform: MT5, RoboForex
• AI: GPT-5.1/Claude/Gemini (person selects supplier)

What This Truly Means:

That is nothing like the opposite two.

39% win price. Most merchants see this and run. “It loses 61% of trades? No thanks.”

However this is what they’re lacking:

• Common win: 1,056.40 pips / $11.32
• Common loss: -576.34 pips / -$6.38
• Expectancy: 66.5 pips / $0.59 per commerce

It wins massive, loses small. The other of GBP Grasp.

If you win solely 39% of the time however your common win ($11.32) is sort of 2x your common loss ($6.38), the maths works. Revenue issue of 1.15 proves it is worthwhile, simply barely.

701 trades in a brief timeframe. Common commerce period of 55 minutes means that is scalping. Excessive frequency, fast in-and-out, AI making choices on each setup.

30.74% most drawdown is excessive. Much like Gold Guardian. This isn’t a conservative system.

What Stunned Me:

The commerce frequency. 701 trades vs 109 (Gold Guardian) vs 951 (GBP Grasp over for much longer interval). AI is energetic. It is analyzing, deciding, executing consistently.

Additionally shocked: it truly works with 39% win price. Most merchants are conditioned to suppose “excessive win price = good EA.” This proves that is unsuitable. Expectancy and revenue issue matter extra.

The Comparability No one Reveals You

Let me put all three side-by-side:

*Alpha Pulse AI month-to-month achieve is early information, not consultant of long-term common

What This Desk Reveals:

1. Excessive win price doesn’t suggest higher. GBP Grasp (92%) and Alpha Pulse AI (39%) are each worthwhile. Completely different approaches, each work.
2. Drawdown tolerance is private. GBP Grasp’s 16.79% vs Gold Guardian’s 32.71%. Identical month-to-month achieve (~8.5%), vastly totally different psychological journey.
3. Commerce frequency varies wildly. 109 trades vs 701 trades vs 951 trades. Some EAs are affected person. Some are aggressive.
4. Revenue issue tells the actual story. Gold Guardian’s 4.44 is outstanding. Alpha Pulse AI’s 1.15 is marginal. GBP Grasp’s 2.24 is stable.

The Portfolio Query (That I Cannot Reply But)

This is what everybody needs to know: “Ought to I run all three without delay?”

Trustworthy reply: I do not know but.

I am nonetheless testing Alpha Pulse AI. It isn’t in my fundamental portfolio. The information you see is ahead testing, proving the idea works, however not sufficient to guess critical capital but.

However this is the theoretical framework for working a number of EAs (whether or not these three or any mixture):

Rule 1: Asset Correlation Issues

GBP Grasp trades GBPUSD. Gold Guardian and Alpha Pulse AI commerce XAUUSD.

GBP/USD and Gold usually have unfavourable correlation (when USD strengthens, gold weakens, and vice versa). This implies:

• GBP Grasp and Gold EAs may stability one another
• When one is in drawdown, the opposite may be profiting
• Portfolio volatility might be decrease than particular person EA volatility

However correlation is not fixed. Throughout risk-off occasions, all the things can drop collectively.

Rule 2: Drawdown Stacking Is Actual

If GBP Grasp hits 16.79% drawdown AND Gold Guardian hits 32.71% drawdown concurrently, your portfolio might be down 40%+ relying on capital allocation.

Are you able to survive that psychologically?

Rule 3: Capital Allocation Is All the things

Do not cut up capital equally. Allocate based mostly on:

• Threat tolerance: Extra capital to lower-DD programs (GBP Grasp)
• Conviction: Extra capital to confirmed, high-sample programs
• Diversification objectives: Steadiness high-WR and low-WR programs

Instance allocation (theoretical):

• 50% GBP Grasp (lowest DD, highest commerce rely, confirmed)
• 30% Gold Guardian (larger DD however wonderful revenue issue)
• 20% Alpha Pulse AI (experimental, early information)

Rule 4: Handbook Interference Will Kill You

Operating a number of EAs means a number of temptations to intervene.

GBP Grasp in drawdown? “Ought to I flip it off?”
Alpha Pulse AI shedding 5 trades in a row? “Ought to I modify settings?”
Gold Guardian makes a giant win? “Ought to I withdraw earnings now?”

Each guide intervention is a violation. That is the place Buying and selling Agenda turns into important—it stops you from touching dwell EAs.

Rule 5: Monitor, Do not Micromanage

Every day guidelines for a number of EAs:

• ✅ VPS working?
• ✅ All EAs energetic with right settings?
• ✅ Dealer spreads regular?
• ✅ Information filter functioning?
• ✅ Drawdown inside Guardrails?

That is it. 2 minutes max. Then stroll away.

What The Actual Information Truly Teaches

After analyzing 951 + 109 + 701 = 1,761 actual trades throughout three totally different programs, this is what stands out:

Lesson 1: Backtests Do not Seize Psychology

All three EAs most likely had stunning backtests. However are you able to deal with 32.71% drawdown in real-time?

Watching your account drop $3,271 on a $10,000 account is totally different than seeing a pink line on a backtest chart. Your mind screams “STOP THE BLEEDING!” though the system is working as designed.

Lesson 2: Pattern Dimension Reveals Fact

109 trades (Gold Guardian) is attention-grabbing information. 951 trades (GBP Grasp) is statistical significance. Extra trades = extra confidence within the edge.

Alpha Pulse AI with 701 trades in a brief timeframe is high-frequency validation, however wants extra time to show long-term viability.

Lesson 3: Revenue Issue > Win Charge

Gold Guardian: 95% win price, 4.44 revenue issue = wonderful
Alpha Pulse AI: 39% win price, 1.15 revenue issue = marginal however worthwhile

Win price is self-importance. Revenue issue is actuality.

Lesson 4: Completely different Types, Completely different Tolerances

• Love consistency? GBP Grasp (92% WR, 16.79% DD)
• Need residence runs? Gold Guardian (95% WR, 32.71% DD, 4.44 PF)
• Inquisitive about AI? Alpha Pulse AI (39% WR, experimental)

Match the EA to your psychology, not another person’s outcomes.

Lesson 5: Verification Issues

All three alerts are Myfxbook verified. Inexperienced badge. Actual dealer. No video games.

If an EA does not have verified, public monitor report, assume it is backtest bait.

Learn how to Truly Use This Data

If You are Evaluating EAs:

1. Demand Myfxbook verification. No excuses.
2. Take a look at drawdown first, not achieve proportion. Are you able to survive the worst day?
3. Verify pattern measurement. 100+ trades minimal earlier than trusting the stats.
4. Confirm revenue issue > 1.5 for confidence (1.15-1.5 is marginal).
5. Match technique to your psychology. Excessive WR or low WR? Fast trades or affected person holds?

If You are Operating A number of EAs:

1. Begin with one. Show you may deal with it with out interference.
2. Add a second solely after 3+ months of hands-off self-discipline with the primary.
3. Use Buying and selling Agenda to forestall guide interference (the #1 killer).
4. Set portfolio-level Guardrails:
   • Max portfolio DD restrict (e.g., 20%)
   • Every day portfolio loss restrict
   • Particular person EA pause triggers
5. Evaluation weekly, not day by day. Let the programs work.

If You are Testing New EAs:

1. Ahead check with small capital (what I am doing with Alpha Pulse AI).
2. Give it 3+ months minimal earlier than including to fundamental portfolio.
3. Monitor correlation with current EAs if including to portfolio.
4. Doc all the things in Buying and selling Agenda (why you added it, what you count on, once you’ll overview).

The Trustworthy Actuality Verify

This is what I am not saying:

❌ “Run all three and get wealthy”
❌ “These outcomes are assured to proceed”
❌ “A number of EAs = diversified security”
❌ “Copy my precise setup”

This is what I am saying:

✅ Actual Myfxbook information beats backtest guarantees
✅ Completely different EAs swimsuit totally different merchants
✅ Drawdown tolerance is extra necessary than achieve proportion
✅ Handbook interference kills extra accounts than dangerous EAs
✅ Verification and pattern measurement matter greater than advertising and marketing

The information is public. You possibly can confirm each quantity on this put up. That is the purpose.

Take Motion (Primarily based on Actual Information)

Step 1: Confirm The Indicators Your self

Do not belief my evaluation. Verify the Myfxbook hyperlinks:

Inexperienced verification badge = actual dealer, actual cash, actual outcomes.

Step 2: Construct Self-discipline Earlier than Including EAs

📅 Obtain Buying and selling Agenda Begin Pack (free) – The system that forestalls guide interference with dwell EAs.

Earlier than you run one EA, not to mention a number of, you want a system that stops you from touching them.

DoIt Methodology takes 10 seconds per day to verify EA standing with out interfering. 500+ merchants utilizing it. 30% discount in guide interference.

→ Get Buying and selling Agenda Begin Pack

Step 3: Consider With The 7-Level Guidelines

Earlier than working ANY EA, consider it correctly:

💡 Obtain the 7-Level Guidelines (free) – The framework that separates actual EAs from backtest bait.

All three alerts analyzed on this put up rating 6-7/7 on the guidelines. That is not coincidence.

→ Get 7-Level EA Guidelines

Step 4: Begin With ONE EA

Do not leap to a number of EAs. Show you may run one with out interference for 3+ months first.

Decide based mostly in your psychology:

• Conservative? Begin with decrease drawdown programs
• Aggressive? Larger danger, larger reward
• Inquisitive about AI? Ahead check with small capital

Primarily based on this evaluation:

However begin with one.

The underside line: Actual Myfxbook information beats advertising and marketing guarantees. 1,761 verified trades educate greater than 1,000 backtest charts. Match the EA to your psychology, not your greed.

These three alerts present totally different approaches to profitability. None are excellent. All have drawdowns. The query is not “which is finest?” It is “which matches the way you suppose?”

Reply that, and also you’re forward of 90% of merchants chasing the “holy grail.”

P.S. — In the event you’re working a number of EAs and battling guide interference (tweaking settings, turning them off throughout drawdown, and so forth.), Buying and selling Agenda’s EA Guardrails module is particularly designed for this. Identical 10-second framework, totally different utility. Prevents the #1 reason for EA failure: the dealer.